The EPR Juggling Act: Agency Enforcement, Pending Litigation, and a Bond-Conditioned Reprieve for NAW Members
Seven U.S. states now have packaging extended producer responsibility (EPR) laws: California, Colorado, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon and Washington. In Maine, Maryland, Minnesota and Washington, the programs are still being set up and producers’ obligations to join a producer responsibility organization (PRO) and pay fees have not yet taken effect, so there is nothing yet to enforce. In three states, however (Oregon, Colorado and California), compliance deadlines have passed, and two of them (Oregon and Colorado) have begun taking steps to bring noncompliant producers into compliance.
For producers in those three states, compliance has become something of a juggling act. Regulators are beginning to act, starting with notices and warnings rather than fines, but with substantial penalties available if those steps fail. Competitors that pay their share may also turn to the courts to address the “free rider” problem. Because each state’s total program costs are divided among the producers that participate, every producer that fails to pay raises the fees paid by those that do. At the same time, constitutional challenges are pending in all three states. In Oregon, a federal court has now conditionally granted relief to one trade association’s members while their appeal is pending, but that relief has not yet taken effect and will not cover anyone else.[1]
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon granted the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors (NAW) a stay and injunction pending its appeal to the Ninth Circuit. The order reinstates, for NAW members only, the preliminary injunction that ended in August when the court upheld Oregon’s law after trial. It comes with an important condition: it takes effect only once NAW deposits with the court a bond, renewed and adjusted each year, roughly equal to the fees NAW members would owe for 2027. The parties must now confer on the amount; if they cannot agree, the court will set it. Until the bond is approved and deposited, there is no hold on enforcement against anyone. Even after the bond is posted, producers that are not NAW members remain fully subject to the law.
The court’s reasoning is worth noting, because it bears directly on the free-rider problem. The court found that NAW members who pay their fees would likely be unable to recover them if NAW wins on appeal. But it also agreed with Oregon that letting a business put off a major expense for years, interest-free, gives it a real advantage over competitors that pay, calling this “basic business economics.” The bond was the court’s answer: NAW members are protected if they win, but they gain little or no cash-flow advantage while the appeal is pending. Weighing those pressures starts with understanding how enforcement works in each state.
Oregon was the first state to start the enforcement process. Circular Action Alliance (CAA), the state’s only PRO, began invoicing producers in mid-2025. In the third quarter of 2025, CAA sent Notices of Delinquency to producers that allegedly had not registered, reported or paid fees, giving them ninety (90) days to come into compliance. Producers that remained noncompliant were referred to the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), which sent warning letters in March 2026 giving them thirty (30) days to comply. Producers that still did not comply were named in a list of noncompliant producers published on CAA’s website on April 9, 2026. As of this writing, there is no indication that DEQ has taken the next step, which would be to refer cases to its Office of Compliance and Enforcement. Once NAW posts its bond, enforcement against NAW members will be on hold while the appeal is pending; for every other producer, the process continues.
Colorado is following a similar timeline. CAA, which is also Colorado’s PRO, first invoiced producers in January 2026, with payment due in February. According to Interchange 360’s October newsletter,[2] the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) has now begun sending Notices of Possible Non-Compliance to producers. In both Oregon and Colorado, then, the state agency’s first formal notices came roughly eight to nine months after CAA sent its first invoices. Colorado also differs from Oregon in one important respect: since July 1, 2025, producers that do not participate in an approved program have been barred from selling covered materials in the state.
California’s EPR law offers producers a fairly extensive negotiated path to compliance. Before assessing a penalty, the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) may accept a corrective action plan, in which a producer proposes specific measures to come into compliance over a period of up to 24 months. A producer that follows its plan avoids penalties and stays off the state’s noncompliance list. CAA, which also serves as California’s PRO, sent its first California invoices on August 31, 2026, with payment due October 15, 2026. Only a few months have passed since those invoices went out, and it is not yet clear how CAA or CalRecycle will respond to producers that have not paid. If California follows the pattern seen in Oregon and Colorado, however, outreach to noncompliant producers could begin by mid-2027. Action may come even sooner, because beginning January 1, 2027, producers that are not participating in an approved program may not sell covered materials in California.
Fines and penalties vary among the three state programs, with the highest in California, at up to $50,000 per day of noncompliance. In general, penalties are not assessed at the statutory maximum. Instead, they are based on a variety of factors, including good-faith efforts to comply and the economic benefit derived from noncompliance, which would include, at a minimum, the unpaid fees (or “dues,” as they are called in Colorado).
Enforcement may not come only from state agencies. None of the three EPR statutes includes a citizen-suit provision allowing private parties to enforce it directly, but producers that pay their share may look for other ways to pursue competitors that do not. California’s Unfair Competition Law (Business and Professions Code § 17200) allows suits over any “unlawful” business practice, including a violation of another statute. A competitor that can show it lost money or property as a result could seek an injunction or restitution, although not damages, and such claims based on EPR violations remain untested. The Oregon court’s recognition that avoiding EPR fees gives nonpaying producers a real competitive advantage may lend some support to such claims, although that finding was made in a different context. Oregon’s Unlawful Trade Practices Act and the Colorado Consumer Protection Act offer less room, because both are aimed mainly at deceptive practices that harm consumers, and failing to pay EPR fees is not obviously deceptive.
Finally, the pending litigation brings producers back to the juggling act. Oregon’s experience shows what court relief can look like in practice. NAW won a preliminary injunction in February 2026, lost it when the court upheld the law in August, and won it back in November, but only on the condition that its members set aside roughly what they would have paid anyway. Even when relief comes, then, it may not relieve producers of the cost of compliance. It may simply redirect that cost into a bond held by the court.
No injunction is currently in effect in any of the three states, and none covers producers outside the challenging trade group. California’s sales ban, in particular, is likely to take effect before a court could rule on any request for a preliminary injunction. Once it does, a producer selling without participating will be committing a clear, visible violation, making private claims by compliant competitors more likely. Producers that hold off on compliance in hopes of court relief run the risk that it never comes, or that it comes with conditions that make waiting no cheaper than paying. Either way, they remain exposed to both agency enforcement and private claims in the meantime.
[1] To date, the only court to rule on the merits of a constitutional challenge to a state packaging EPR program has upheld it. After a five-day bench trial, the U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon rejected the plaintiff’s Commerce Clause and due process claims and upheld Oregon’s Plastic Pollution and Recycling Modernization Act in full. Nat’l Ass’n of Wholesaler-Distributors v. Feldon, No. 3:25-cv-01334-SI (D. Or. Aug. 27, 2026) (findings of fact and conclusions of law), appeal docketed, No. 26-6404 (9th Cir. Sept. 24, 2026). The district court has since granted a stay and injunction pending appeal, effective only upon NAW’s deposit of a court-approved bond. Id., ECF 218 (D. Or. Nov. 16, 2026).
[2] Interchange 360 members comply with Colorado’s EPR law through Interchange 360’s own CDPHE-approved program rather than through CAA.





Comments